Ranking The Most Influential hip hop presidencies
Hot Takes
Based on timelines, which presidential legacy since hip hop's birth in 1973 best shaped the history of the genre in accordance with politics and American society at large.
NOVEMBER 20, 2023
BY HARPSICHORD
Digital illustration of a fake Mt. Rushmore of Presidents Obama, Reagan, Trump, and Bush.
Second ranking
George W. Bush
43rd president
Hip hop culture got turned upside down when the Jr. son of the genre’s most hated president got into office. With a series of disastrous and controversial events taking place, rappers often found themselves calling out Bush in their music.
2001 - 2009
The Bush Era Events sparking call outs
The 2000 Florida Recount That Stayed On Kanye’s Brain
While Bush was serving his second term, Sting, and his band The Police, had a headlining set during the Live Earth benefit concert on July 7, 2007. They brought out Kanye West who freestyled “Al Gore got robbed cause he got my vote.” This sentiment had been expressed earlier by West on the ‘Can’t Tell Me Nothing’ mixtape, where he says “I need Al Gore to recount that vote,” on a freestyle of “Young Folks.”
George W. Bush’s presidency already started out with confusion thanks to the Florida recount. While many believed his opponent, then VP, Al Gore won Florida, which would have helped win the electoral college, the Supreme Court’s swing vote of Sandra Day O’ Connor gave Bush the victory.
The Twin Towers And Jay-Z’s Blueprints
Hip hop conspiracy theorists believe that The Notorious B.I.G. predicted the 9/11 Twin Tower attacks years prior to his death and the actual event. However, what they confuse is “blow up like the World Trade,” actually referenced the 1993 bombings.
read about the blueprint: 17 Essential Mafioso rap albums
When the twin towers actually did fall, JAY-Z was at a turning point of his career. As he said on his “9/11 Freestyle,” “I drop the same date as the Twin Towers/ I show power.” Despite that event occurring, ‘The Blueprint’ went on to be the No. 1 selling album of the week. News outlets cited how teens and early 20-something fans didn’t care about the crisis enough to stop them from buying a highly anticipated album. A month later he would perform “Izzo (H.O.V.A.)” at The Concert For New York City. A year later on “Blueprint²,” JAY-Z claims “When the Twin Towers fell, I was the first in line/Donatin’ proceeds off every ticket sold.” His attitude took a turn in 2009 when he metaphorically declared “I was gonna 9/11 'em, but they didn't need the help," when discussing his competitors on ‘The Blueprint 3’s “Thank You.”
No Child Left Behind Act And Kanye’s Late Response On Wax
The No Child Left Behind Act was introduced by John Boehner, a Republican from Ohio on March 22, 2001. One of the main provisions of the legislation was providing federal funding to schools that engaged in standardized testing. As a part of his 2000 campaign, George W. Bush promised education reform. Both houses passed the legislation with nearly unanimous votes, and Bush signed it into law on January 8, 2002.
But what became clear with No Child Left Behind is that it ironically set out to penalize schools in districts that already had low education performance. State governments created the proficiency marks– and if a school consistently missed the passing threshold, their funding was reduced. This consequently meant lack of money for updated textbooks and material that helped with standardized tests that became harder, as well as pay for teachers. There was also the consequence of “gaming the system,” by simply passing students through grade levels to decrease dropout rates and not to alert the government of poor performance at schools.
On today’s internet, the No Child Left Behind Act is often referred to as a meme when someone states something stupid online. Bush is often blamed for an individual (or a group of individuals) making a faux pas regarding information that should have been learned in school. For his 2021 album, ‘Donda,’ Kanye included a short interlude named after the act, where the premise is not to abandon a child when they are failing.
The iraq War
Timeline
Weapons of Mass Destruction and Xzibit’s Response Album
Prior to the Invasion of Iraq, The Bush administration alerted American citizens of possible “weapons of mass destruction” existing in the Middle East. During his 2002 State of the Union address he focused on an “axis of evil” that included Iraq. In 2003, Bush furthered his agenda with a State of the Union address that targeted Saddam Hussein– claiming that the Iraqi president created those weapons. That included but not limited to anthrax and nuclear weapons. Eventually through investigations and journalistic reporting, it would be revealed that Hussein did not orchestrate such.
Xzibit released Weapons of Mass Destruction at the end of 2004, as a result of Bush’s re-election and the on-going Iraq War. On the opening track, “State of the Union,” the rapper mocks the 2002 address,
splicing the words of George Bush where it seems the President was referring to himself as a “dictator.” “My ultimate ambitions are to control the peoples of the United States, and to blackmail the rest of the world with weapons of mass terror. Weapons of Mass Destruction,” finishes the intro. On “L.A.X.,” the rapper claims over a West Coast g-funk beat, “You better get ready for war.”
The Invasion of Iraq, Capture of Saddam Hussein, Ja Rule’s “Clap Back,” Mos Def’s War, and the re-release of Eric B. & Rakim’s “Casualties of War”
On March 17, 2003 at 8:01 PM in the Cross Hall of the White House, President Bush stood in front of the nation in a televised address. “My fellow citizens,” started the President. “Events in Iraq have now reached the final days of decision. For more than a decade, the United States and other nations have pursued patient and honorable efforts to disarm the Iraqi regime without war.” He gave Saddam Hussein 48 hours to surrender power to American forces.
On March 19, 2003, the Invasion of Iraq began with air strikes. That night from the Oval Office, Bush informed the nation at 10:16 P.M.: “My fellow citizens, at this hour, American and coalition forces are in the early stages of military operations to disarm Iraq.” Ground efforts proceeded on March 20, before capturing the capital of Baghdad on April 9. Saddam Hussein was forced to give up his presidency, and went into hiding. On December 13, 2003, he was captured by American troops during Operation Red Dawn.
Picture: President Bush addresses the Nation on March 20, 2003 from the Oval Office about the Invasion of Iraq.
On “Clap Back” – a diss at 50 Cent and Eminem– Ja Rule referenced the leader with, “It's real! Hussein what's happenin' n!gga?/I see you, aight Shadow what's poppin' blat!” Throughout the chorus, Ja Rule shouts “Let’s take ‘em to war.” In another bar, he claims “Let's take 'em to war, n!gga, like Bush and Saddam, Imma find out where Em Laden's hidin’” – a reference to al-Queda’s leader, Osama. The song reached No. 44 on the Billboard Hot 100, and peaked at No. 12 on the Rap Songs Chart
On June 30, 2004, Hussein was transferred from custody of the US on Camp Cropper in Baghdad to the interim-acting Iraqi government. The Iraqi’s began a trial process against Hussein for his crimes against humanity with the first hearing happening on July 1, 2004. In October, Mos Def– who went by (and still does) Yasiin Bey– released “War” where he starts with “War is a global economic phenomenon.” Utilizing repetitive terms like “go get my money” and “f*ck you pay me,” he criticizes how war oddly leads to economic gains through the acts of people supporting violent deaths.
On October 19, 2005, Hussein’s trial commenced for killing 148 Shia Muslims during the 1982 Dujail Massacre. In the midst of this trial, Eric B. & Rakim’s 1992 cut, “Casualties of War” received a “Radical Radio Edit” on their greatest hits compilation, Gold . The album dropped on June 14, 2005. This coincidental release marked a sign of irony– as the original song was about the effects of the Gulf War during Bush Sr.’s administration. On the track, Rakim raps, Allah is my only protection/But wait a minute, Saddam Hussein prays the same.”
After being found guilty on November 5, 2006, Hussein was sentenced to death execution style. A hanging took place on December 30– the first day of the Islamic holiday, Eid al-Adha.
Eminem’s “Mosh Pit” and Bush’s 2004 Re-Election
In the midst of the war, President Bush was up for re-election against Democratic candidate, John Kerry. On October 26, 2004, Eminem released an animated music video for “Mosh Pit.” As a cartoon character he performs a concert for a group of fans– mobilizing them to storm the White House. Instead the plot twist is that these militant individuals are signing up to vote, with a message at the end for real American citizens to do so on November 2. Bush ended up winning the electoral college and the popular vote.
Hurricane Katrina and Lil Wayne’s Response for Nola
On August 30, 2005, a category 5 hurricane devastated the Gulf Coast– primarily bringing national attention to New Orleans. Hurricane Katrina caused over 1,800 fatalities and an estimated $125 billion in damages. The Bush Administration and FEMA were criticized to their late response to the natural disaster– as the news cycles looped coverage of stranded and poor citizens affected by the storm. Aside from Kanye West’s infamous “George Bush doesn’t care about Black people” outburst during a telethon, Lil Wayne released the diss “Georgia Bush.”
The Great Recession and Ludacris Grammy-winning song
Due to the catastrophic events not only happening in the United States, but also the world, the economy hit a “Great Recession.” Encapsulated by a housing crisis, skyrocketing unemployment, and stock market crashes, Jeezy summarized it best in 2008 album, ‘Recession’ “everybody broke.” Prior, Ludacris took a political rap turn on his Grammy winning Best Rap Album, ‘Release Therapy.’ On his single, “Slap,” Ludacris commentates on this while also dissing Bush’s policies.
-
Originally MTV had planned on organizing the free concert for their Peabody-winning "Choose or Lose" campaign, but after Los Angeles city officials wouldn’t offer the appropriate permits, MTV canceled their involvement.
-
Speaking to CNN’s Showbiz Tonight Snoop Dogg’s full quote: “I'm going to vote for Gore because he's from the Clinton administration and I'm down with Clinton. You know what I'm saying, the world is cool like it is, we don't need no change.”
First ranking
Barack Obama
44th president
Hip hop during Reagan’s leadership consisted of an uncanny balance of content that flaunted wealth and the genre’s commercial growth, but also criticized poverty, censorship, and the war on drugs. Hip hop legends like N.W.A. paved the way, while a new generation of leaders such as Jay-Z and Nas grew up on hip hop as a means to survive.
2009 - 2017
-
KRS-One would sample the first hip hop song to go No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100, with “Step into a World (Rapture's Delight)” in 1997.
-
“Don't push me cause I'm close to the edge/I'm trying not to lose my head /It's like a jungle sometimes /It makes me wonder how I keep from goin' under” became the lyrics of one of mainstream pop’s first socially conscious hip hop records.